What we caught, we threw away. We kept what we didn't catch. What was it that we kept?
Clue 1
The answer is something gross and creepy, though not necessarily Halloween-related.Clue 2
It's a creepy-crawly thing, not far off from bugs on your eyebrows or in your mouth, maybe a little further north.Reveal answer
Lice. You catch them and throw them away, but you keep the ones you didn't catch.