Joe, wearing a mask and carrying an empty sack, leaves his house. An hour later, he returns with a full sack. He goes into a room and turns out the light. What's going on?
Reveal answer
Joe is a kid who went trick-or-treating on Halloween; he came home with a sack full of candy and went to bed.
What we caught, we threw away. We kept what we didn't catch. What was it that we kept?
Clue 1The answer is something gross and creepy, though not necessarily Halloween-related.Clue 2It's a creepy-crawly thing, not far off from bugs on your eyebrows or in your mouth, maybe a little further north.
Reveal answer
Lice. You catch them and throw them away, but you keep the ones you didn't catch.
My wife was attacked by a burglar when I was on my way home from work. She stabbed him with a butcher knife and killed him. The detective said it was an obvious case of self-defense. When I next talked to her, she said, "I heard the doorbell. I thought it was you, but then a masked man jumped out at me as soon as I opened the door." I said, "You must have been so scared, but you're safe now," and hugged her tightly. How did she kill the burglar so fast when he attacked her at the door?
Reveal answer
She came to the door holding the butcher knife because she thought it was her husband and was planning to kill him; the burglar happened to be the one at the door.