Sometimes blood and often milk, thicker than water and soft as silk. You need bones to make a batch, so open up and down the hatch. What is it?
Clue 1
Is it an object? Yes.Clue 2
Is it a type of food? Yes, a type of food in the bag.Reveal answer
Pudding (gelatin is made from bones). The hosts never reached it, and the reveal is only implied by the pudding in his bag.Answer implied: not stated outright on the show.