Despite my name, it's not even a draw, but I'm the best killer of them all. But since what I counter anyone would mind, and I'm not over the top, I'm easy to find. (In the written riddle, "counter" and "over the" are underlined.)
Clue 1
"Counter" and "over the" are underlined in the riddle.Reveal answer
Tylenol: an over-the-counter painkiller, with a name that sounds like "tie" (not even a draw).