Riddle Archive Hey Riddle Riddle

From #372 My Hearts Don't Lie w/ Joey Bland · 2025-09-03 · Episode on Patreon ↗

⏱ 25:22listener

A corrupt and evil king has been condemning people to death by public execution. To appear fair, the condemned are shown two folded pieces of paper, one supposedly reading "innocent" and the other "guilty", and must unfold one and show it to the crowd: "innocent" means freedom, "guilty" means immediate beheading. Everyone so far has drawn "guilty" and been beheaded. One day the king condemns you, and you realize both pieces of paper say "guilty." How do you survive?

Clue 1Your hands are free. You may not speak on the platform, or signal that you know both papers say guilty.
Clue 2You are using the king's trick against him; the answer will not involve showing both pieces of paper to the crowd.
Clue 3Only one piece of paper must be shown to the public.
Reveal answer
Quickly swallow one of the papers. The crowd is then forced to look at the remaining paper, which reads "guilty", and they must assume you ate the one that said "innocent".
Submitted by Ben Martinelli
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itlateral thinkingstorylogic

Search all riddles Open in the archive