Jennifer and Madeline go out for lunch and both order iced tea. Jennifer has an appointment later, so she finishes her drink quickly and gets two more. Soon after, Madeline drops dead but Jennifer is unharmed. The police rule it a murder and find that there was poison in the ice. Why didn't the person who drank quickly die?
Reveal answer
The poison was in the ice cubes. Jennifer drank her tea fast, before the ice melted and released the poison, while Madeline sipped slowly as the cubes dissolved. (The hosts' joking "real" answer is that she peed out the poison.)