Riddle Archive Hey Riddle Riddle

From #176 Fanta Claus · 2021-12-02 · Episode on Patreon ↗

⏱ 41:34listener

In a certain kingdom, the natural law is that the only antidote to a poison is a stronger poison (if poison X is stronger than poison Y, drinking Y and then X leaves you fine). The king has his scribe and royal chemist each concoct the strongest poison they know. They swap poisons, each takes a sip of the other's poison and then a sip of their own, so whoever has the strongest poison survives. The night before, the scribe realizes he can't beat the chemist and makes a plan to survive; the chemist anticipates the scribe's plan and makes his own. The next morning they exchange poisons exactly as agreed. The scribe dies and the chemist lives, but the king doesn't get what he wanted (the strongest poison). What was the scribe's plan, and what was the chemist's?

Clue 1The rules stay the same: they exchange poisons and drink as planned.
Clue 2The chemist's cup held only water, and so did the scribe's.
Reveal answer
The scribe drank poison beforehand and filled his cup with water, expecting the chemist's stronger poison to cancel it out. The chemist foresaw this and also filled his cup with plain water. The scribe drank only water after his earlier poison and died, the chemist survived, and the king ended up with nothing but water instead of a strong poison.
Submitted by Susie
Show category & result
✗ Stumped the hostslogicstory

Search all riddles Open in the archive