A piece of metal through a hole in your body. Don't get one at Claire's; they'll put it in shoddy. (Answer contains the letters of "Erin" in order.)
Reveal answer
Earring (the hosts also noted that "piercing" and Neosporin contain E-R-I-N).
From #138 Nose Fish · 2021-03-10 · Episode on Patreon ↗