Riddle Archive Hey Riddle Riddle

From #116 Three Butlers Living in the Very Same House · 2020-10-07 · Episode on Patreon ↗

⏱ 14:40listener

The Case of the Arrowless Bow. The chief clue in the death of Susie was an archery bow lying on the carpet at the top of a narrow, twisting flight of stairs in her home. Susie was found at the bottom of the stairs, her neck broken. The sheriff tells you that she was pushed, and hard. As far as they can determine, the only thing missing from the home is Susie's famous Luzon diamond. Your theory is that Susie heard burglars, tied the diamond to an arrow and shot it out the open window, planning to reclaim it later. The prime suspect is Kevin, who has been trying to buy the diamond for years. You hide the bow. As Kevin is brought in by police, the sheriff says Susie was pushed down the stairs and the Luzon diamond is missing. Kevin insists he knows nothing about Susie's death, but says, “Find the diamond, you dumb cop. I'll buy it.” You tell Kevin the diamond won't be hard to locate and, looking up the narrow twisting staircase, add, “It's only a narrow flight away.” “Let's go outside and look,” Kevin exclaims. You tell the sheriff to arrest him. Why?

Clue 1There's an operative word in there that clues you in.
Reveal answer
You said “narrow flight,” but Kevin heard “arrow flight.” He only knew to look outside because he knew the diamond had been shot out the window on an arrow. That could only mean he was there.
Submitted by Drew Davenport (credited as a Yahoo user)
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itmysterywordplay

Search all riddles Open in the archive