“Three Boatmen.” Equipment was stolen from a marina and the three witnesses disagree; only one is telling the truth. Arigio says Benizzi is lying. Benizzi says Cipolla is lying. Cipolla says the other two men are both lying. Which one should the boatmaster trust?
Reveal answer
Benizzi. If he is truthful, Cipolla is lying and Arigio (who says Benizzi lies) is lying too, which fits. The hosts debated it and the final answer was never stated clearly.Answer implied: not stated outright on the show.