They come out and file in rank, some applaud while others just "thank". Trapped in here, Pete, for leaving his seat, bringing snack and the nastiest drink. (An anagram is hidden in the riddle: "thank, trapped in here Pete" is six words' worth of letters and relates to the live shows.)
Clue 1
It's related to the live shows; someone on the show does something special at them.Clue 2
Erin eats the paper and drinks the pen.Reveal answer
The anagram "thank, trapped in here Pete" rearranges to "eat the paper, drink the pen", a reference to Erin's bit at live shows.