Riddle Archive Hey Riddle Riddle

From #63 A Pun in the Pool · 2019-10-02 · Episode on Patreon ↗

⏱ 32:33main

Two men stood on a softball field and practiced throwing and catching just before a game. "Over here," shouted Ned, slapping his fist into his mitt. Ted threw the softball to him. "Good catch. Throw me a grounder," shouted Ted. Ned returned the ball by throwing it along the ground as requested. "Now a high one. Right here." Ted threw the ball high in the air and Ned ran about 10 feet to his left, reached up and caught the ball easily. "Good arm, but your aim is a little crooked," he announced. "No, it isn't," replied Ted. "So what's wrong with throwing the high ball right to where I was standing?" retorted Ned. Explain.

Clue 1Did Ted intend to give Ned practice at running to catch a high ball? No, just throwing the high ball.
Clue 2Could Ted have aimed the ball directly at Ned if he wanted to? Yes.
Clue 3Is their location significant? No.
Reveal answer
They weren't alone. A teammate was standing behind Ned, and Ted feared that if Ned missed a high ball aimed right at him, it would hit the teammate. A throw straight at someone's body would at least be deflected if missed, so Ted aimed it high and off to the side.
Show category & result
✗ Stumped the hostslateral thinkingstory

Search all riddles Open in the archive