"The teacher marked you wrong," Jimmy sang out teasingly during school recess. "You didn't put dots on all your eyes." "Is that so?" countered Timmy. "Bet you don't know how to draw a small eye with a dot on it," he challenged. Jimmy did so, and Timmy looked defeated. A few minutes later Timmy retorted, "Well, now I have dots over my eyes and you don't." One glance at Timmy and Jimmy burst out laughing. So did Timmy. Half the class did too. Explain.
Clue 1
He put something on his face above his eyes.Reveal answer
A pun on "dotting your i's": Timmy had drawn dots on his face over his own eyes, so he literally had dots over his eyes (and Jimmy didn't). This reading is uncertain because the answer was only loosely summed up on air.