A merchant waits alone on his loaded boat for his servant. The boatman decides it would be easy to kill him and steal his goods, so he drowns the merchant and takes the goods home. To make an alibi, he goes to the merchant's house and asks why the merchant hadn't come to the boat. The merchant's wife says her husband had left long before. The magistrate speaks with her alone, then with the boatman, who repeats exactly what he said at the house: that when he came to the gate he called, "Mistress, why hasn't the master come down yet?" The magistrate says, "You just confessed." How did the boatman give himself away?
Reveal answer
He called for the mistress of the house rather than asking for the merchant. Only the killer would have known the merchant wasn't home to answer, so he went straight to the wife.