A woman walked into a police station. "I want to report a pickpocket," she announced. A man staggered in behind her, his hand in her coat pocket. "Arrest that man," she continued, pointing at him. He was arrested, tried, and convicted of picking pockets. Why did he enter the police station in a posture that obviously suggested his crime?
Clue 1
Was he really a pickpocket? Yes.Clue 2
Did he want to be arrested? No.Clue 3
Did he act rationally? Yes.Reveal answer
She had sewn fish hooks into her coat pocket. When he caught his hand on them she told him he was coming to the police station with her, and he went along to avoid serious injury to his hand (based on a story about the wife of inventor Peter Cooper).