A man is on a train that is full. He notices a person with a missing finger. He walks up to the person and kills them. At the next stop he is questioned by the police, but they let him go. Why?
Clue 1
It's an Ashley Judd movie.Reveal answer
He had been framed for murder because his wife faked her death by cutting off her own finger and leaving it at the scene. After he served his sentence he found her and killed her, but he could not be punished twice for the same crime (the plot of Double Jeopardy).