A woman walked up to a man behind a counter and handed him a book. He looked at it and said, "That will be $4." She paid the man and then walked out without the book. He saw her leave without it, but did not call her back. Why?
Reveal answer
The book was a Bible, the most stolen book, and she had stolen it. By paying for it and leaving it behind she was making amends. (Hosts guessed this quickly; the exact wording of the reveal is thin in the transcript.)Answer implied: not stated outright on the show.