Riddle Archive Hey Riddle Riddle

From #2 My Puzzle Lies Over the Ocean · 2018-08-01 · Episode on Patreon ↗

⏱ 48:22listener

A captain and three of his crewmates are the only survivors of a shipwreck. They are adrift on a lifeboat for many days until one of the crew dies of exposure. The other two use their cutlasses to poke holes in him so his corpse will sink and not attract sharks. Soon the rest are starving. One morning the captain wakes to find that one more crew member has died and sunk, and the remaining one is cooking over a very small fire. "Captain, an albatross landed long enough to be killed. We have food!" The meat, they agree, is the best they have ever tasted, and soon after they are rescued. Many years later, the captain hears of a restaurant serving albatross. He goes there and orders it, but after one mouthful he leaves, goes home, and kills himself. Why?

Reveal answer
The albatross at the restaurant tasted nothing like what he ate on the lifeboat, so he realised the "albatross" he had eaten back then was the body of his crewmate.
Submitted by David F.
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itlateral thinkingstorymystery

Search all riddles Open in the archive