Riddle Archive Hey Riddle Riddle

#387 Lincoln's Lost the Sauce

2025-12-17 · 15 riddles · Listen on Patreon ↗ · Open in the archive

⏱ 17:17listener

On Stanley on were the last words of Babylon. If I were to stand in Stanley's place, it would bring salty tears to people's face. What is it?

Reveal answer
An onion. Replace "Stanley" with "I" and the first line reads "On I on", which spells "onion"; onions make you cry.
Submitted by Ben
Show category & result
✗ Stumped the hostswordplaycipher
Riddle page →
⏱ 29:32listener

We pick but don't choose. We don't come in twos. Periodically smaller, we won't make you taller. The top of the tip, we scratch and we click. Some fancy, some plain, but what is our name?

Reveal answer
Fingernails.
Submitted by Jess
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itwhat am i
Riddle page →
⏱ 33:40listener

I'm one-fourth of a score and used by many. You might find me on the floor. I'm more tempting than a penny. I can get you many a thing, but when spent, I am gone. So get the gift worth giving and use me on Patreon. What am I?

Reveal answer
A five-dollar bill (a score is twenty, so one-fourth is five).
Submitted by Kevin Kevinson
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itwhat am imath
Riddle page →
⏱ 41:55guest

What does a fireplace have in common with a party thrown by new neighbors?

Reveal answer
Both are housewarmings.
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 42:22guest

What does a synchronized diver have in common with a billiards player?

Reveal answer
Pool cues (the hosts landed on this and Sandy moved on without disputing it).Answer implied: not stated outright on the show.
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
punwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 44:09guest

What does a clueless person have in common with a broken sword?

Reveal answer
Both miss the point (no point).
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 45:18guest

What does an idle chatterer have in common with an unskilled marksman?

Reveal answer
Both shoot the breeze.
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 47:03guest

What do popular people have in common with shivering goat babies?

Reveal answer
Both are cool kids (kids as in baby goats, cool as in cold).
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 48:25guest

What does a musically inclined philanthropist have in common with a consenting patient?

Reveal answer
Both are organ donors.
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 50:21guest

What does a menu have in common with Bowdoin College? (The answer involves a homophone; knowing where the college is helps.)

Reveal answer
Both have mains: Bowdoin is in Maine, and a menu has main courses.
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 52:18guest

What does a certain pop star have in common with a very quick seamstress?

Reveal answer
Both are Swift Taylors (Taylor Swift).
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 52:18guest

What does Parcheesi have in common with fatigued pheasants? (Another homophone.)

Reveal answer
Both are board games (bored games).
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 53:54guest

What does the coronation of a new queen have in common with the birth of a baby?

Reveal answer
Crowning (a crowning achievement).
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 54:24guest

What does Popeye have in common with someone who gets almost nothing on their salad?

Reveal answer
Both have only spinach and olive oil (Olive Oyl).
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →
⏱ 57:33guest

What does an old car have in common with a director who quits a Mission Impossible movie?

Reveal answer
Both lack cruise control (Tom Cruise).
Submitted by Sandy
Show category & result
✓ Hosts solved itpunwordplay
Riddle page →