One day when I was six years old, my little sister wouldn't stop crying. It annoyed me so much that I killed her and threw her body down the well. The next day when I peered down into the well, her body had disappeared. When I was 12, I got into an argument with my best friend over something stupid. He made me so angry that I killed him and threw his body down the well. The next day his body had disappeared. When I was 18, my significant other got pregnant... (The same thing happens with her and later with his boss: each time he throws the body down the well and by the next day it is gone. Finally he kills his sick mother and throws her down the well, and her body does not disappear.) What is creepy about this story?
Clue 1Does who the victims were to him matter? Not for most of them, but the last one (his mother) matters.Clue 2Does it matter how they were killed? No.Clue 3One of his victims loved him very much.Clue 4It has to do with what his mother did for him.
Reveal answer
His mother loved him so much that she secretly removed and disposed of every body he dropped down the well. When he killed her, there was no one left to clear away her body.
(Titled "Burglar".) A man is taking a bath. When he gets out, he sees a burglar standing over the dead bodies of his mother, father and little brother. The burglar sees him and runs out the window screaming. What's wrong with this story?
Clue 1It's called "Burglar".
Reveal answer
The narrator is the murderer: he killed his family and was washing off the blood. The burglar came to rob the house, saw the bodies and the killer, and fled in terror.
I was walking home last night when I felt the urge to poop and had to use a creepy old public bathroom at the end of a street of abandoned houses. In the first stall, there was graffiti on the walls. On the right it said, "This bathroom is haunted." On the left it said, "This writing will change." I sat down on the toilet and, while pooping, looked again. On my right it said, "This bathroom is haunted," and on my left it said, "This writing will change." So if the writing doesn't change, that means the bathroom isn't haunted, right? Solve.
Reveal answer
Sitting down facing the opposite way, left and right should have swapped. Since the messages were in the same places, the writing did change, so the bathroom is haunted.